Leadership for Youth Ministry: Theology and PracticeIn my first
paper I examined the links between healthy youth ministry and the
development of healthy congregations. In this paper I will be focusing on a
theology and practice of servant mission leadership, as it relates to my own
role as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator in the Presbyterian Church of
Aotearoa New Zealand. This is in the context of the purpose of the Presbyterian
National Youth Ministry Workgroup: to build healthy youth ministry throughout
the Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand.
As I explore my current role in the
Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand, I will be using the Presbyterian
Church’s call for "servant mission leadership" as a reference point. This is for
two reasons. I believe that a theology and practice of "servant mission
leadership" is central to my ministry. Secondly, a key element of my ministry is
involving other people in the building of healthy youth ministry in the
Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand. The building of healthy youth
ministry in the Presbyterian Church will require people with servant attitudes,
ability to provide focus for the mission of the church with young people, and an
ability to be involved in God’s transformation of the church and New Zealand
society.
I have drawn largely on two authors, Robert
Greenleaf and Kennon Callahan. Greenleaf’s insights into servant leadership were
in the 1970s a welcome contrast to the power-centred management focus of
business and the church. The emphasis on values rather than outcomes is, I
believe, close to the heart of Jesus’ leadership. My theology of leadership has
been strongly influenced by Callahan’s concept of the missionary pastor – the
one who recognises the mission field for what it is and leads the congregation
to be an effective mission agent in that field.
Serve God First
Christian leaders serve God and God’s
interests in the world first. Only secondarily do they serve people. Stevens and
Collins point out that Christian leaders are called by Christ, rather than
merely motivated by needs. That is a core element of the Presbyterian
understanding of call to ministry, a concept central to my theology of ministry.
Leighton Ford points out that the strongest leaders are "those who have received
a strong affirmation of their personhood, in a way that frees them not only to
lead a cause but also to serve others." This is outlined by Paul in the letter
to the Philippians. Jesus, although having the nature of God, stooped to become
one of us, showing us the true nature of a servant. This he did, without relying
on public acclaim or personal reward. As much of my work at a national level is
not seen on a weekly basis, as it was in the parish setting, I have to rely on a
strong sense of motivation and calling rather than commendation.
I am challenged by the role modelling provided
by Jesus in his relationship with the nation of Israel and his followers.
Retrospectively, we see that Jesus in his life, death and resurrection fulfils
the call of one nation, Israel, as it is outlined in the servant songs in
Isaiah. Having lived up to the calling he has received from God to serve with
his life, Jesus releases the servant role to the church, his people scattered
throughout the world. Jesus embodies the character of servant at the same time
as he transforms the corporate life of his followers.
Servant Leadership
This concept of servant leadership was
popularised by Robert Greenleaf in the early 1970s. Greenleaf’s often-quoted
introduction is as follows:
"It begins with the natural feeling that one wants to serve,
to serve first. Then conscious choice brings one to aspire to lead. The
difference manifests itself in the care taken by the servant – first to make
sure that other people's highest priority needs are being served."
"The best test, and difficult to administer, is do those
served grow as persons; do they while being served, become healthier, wiser,
freer, more autonomous, more likely themselves to become servants? And, what is
the effect on the least privileged in society; will they benefit, or at least,
not be further deprived?"
I find the "servant leader" concept invaluable
as I consider my role as leader in a national team of Christians working
alongside young people. I am not here to develop an empire in which the national
church structure benefits. I am called to a task of leadership that equips
others to be servant leaders in their relationships with young people in the
community. My credibility as leader will not just focus on my "production of
goods", but will also stem from my authenticity as a servant growing into a
mature leadership approach modelled on the character of Jesus.
Authentic Leadership
A central element of the life of Jesus was
integrity. His claims to speak truth, and be truth, were backed up by a
lifestyle consistent with those claims. Hopgood talks about the "spiritually
grounded pastor" as being so dependent on the spirit of God that "you go back
again and again for insight, inspiration, strength, and rest, and you can’t do
anything in your ministry without these." Integrity in my ministry as National
Youth Ministry Co-ordinator involves being seen to make decisions in the light
of what I believe God wants. A year ago, a member of my present congregation
challenged me to show that I was not succumbing to "trendy expedience" by
promoting the latest approaches to worship and communication. To be seen to have
integrity, I had to demonstrate that my practice was rooted in what I believed
God called me to be and do. This person recognised my integrity when I talked
openly about the deeply held values that had led me to being innovative.
Concern for People
Servant leadership is marked by a concern for
people. The context of my ministry as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator is
the world of young people in Aotearoa New Zealand. I have stayed involved in
youth ministry primarily because of my deeply held belief that young people need
opportunities to discover the fullness of a relationship with God. One of the
factors in my passion for youth ministry is my belief that children and
teenagers are people as much as adults are. A young person’s experience of God
is as valuable as that of an adult’s. Going even further, I would say that the
experience of Christian community is a gift that may at times be more valuable
to young people than mature adults. Why do I think this? Children and teenagers,
by the nature of their personal development and social environment, are forming
the values, beliefs, and relational skills that they will need for a lifetime.
The transitions being faced by children and young people will shape not only
their lives, but also the broader culture of the community in which they live.
Leader as Listener
Servant leadership is characterised by a focus
on listening intently and reflectively to others in order to identify and
clarify the will of the people. In the context of youth ministry co-ordination,
listening involves gathering people to share vision in workgroups, in Youth
Assemblies, and in seminars. My leadership at a national level serves as an
amplifier for young people and leaders seeking to share their perspective with
their church and community. At the same time, I am in a position to listen
carefully to the perspectives of those whose hard work and vision has provided
an inheritance for today’s young people.
Leader as partner
My role as National Youth Ministry
Co-ordinator is worked out in the context of a number of bicultural
partnerships. The Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand recognises, in its
structure and name at least, an inherent bicultural relationship between Maori
and Pakeha members. The partnership implied in this relationship involved mutual
respect and recognition of the unique contribution made by Maori culture to the
contextualisation of Christianity in New Zealand. The many principles of the
Maori-Pakeha relationship can be applied to the increasing partnerships being
developed as the Presbyterian Church welcomes members who are immigrants from
countries such as the Netherlands, the Cook Islands, Western Samoa, Niue,
Tokelau, Korea, Taiwan, Indonesia and Hong Kong. In my own local setting, the
Methodist component of Tawa Union church brings with it a partnership with a
Tongan congregation. I am in weekly contact with young people from Cook Island,
Rwandan, Samoan, Tongan, Pakeha, Korean and Maori backgrounds.
What is the theological significance of such
multicultural partnerships? I believe that God is uniquely revealed in each
ethnic culture. A significant component of adolescent development is the
formation of identity in relation to roots. The questions "Who am I", and "To
whom will I belong?" are key to the life searches of teenagers and young adults.
Young people in The Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand have an
opportunity to explore Christianity through the eyes not only of their own
ethnic origins but also through the eyes of other cultures. This is worked out
on a practical level in my local youth ministry, in which ethnic variety is
built into the selection of served food, the imagery used, and the settings of
our programmes. At a national level I have the privilege of working with a
policy workgroup consisting of representatives from Maori, Pacific Island and
Pakeha perspectives on youth ministry.
The Trusted Leader
I believe that trustworthiness is required in
leadership of youth ministry at a national level. Hopgood writes that "trustability"
comes as a result both of being known as reliable and being willing to trust
others. He says that risk taking is not part of the characteristic of the
trusted leader but is seen as a result of God’s call and power. People trust me
and my ministry as they get to know me, seeing me "producing the goods" over a
long period of time. I am trusted when I turn up when I said I will, and when I
show competence in challenging situations. I am continuing to work on this,
particularly as I find it hard to say no to tasks even though they may be
difficult to carry out in a reasonable time period.
Building personal confidence in my ministry
involves my being vulnerable as I reveal my values and beliefs, and as I allow
others to do the same. I am currently teaching a course on small group
leadership with Ministry interns at the local Bible College. The key learning
throughout the whole course is the interpersonal skills of building community in
a small group. Over three months I have shared my experiences and perceptions of
life with this group in a way that has sparked willingness in the group to share
deep aspects of their lives. In a similar way I have modelled self-evaluation in
my interaction with youth workers and other congregational leaders, stimulating
readiness among these people to ask hard questions of their own ministry.
Affirming Leadership
Servant leaders accept and recognise others
for their unique gifts and spirits, assuming their good intentions and not
rejecting them as people. My ministry at a national level implies the
recognition that each person in the Church is equipped by the Spirit, with
different contributions to make. The effectiveness of my work is strongly linked
to the extent of my networking across gender, age, and theological boundaries,
and beyond the church. Callahan points out that effective leaders tend to work
in the role of coach rather than as one who continually corrects. He explains
that the purpose of effective leadership is to develop persons, rather than
policies. When speaking to local congregations and their leaders I am most
effective when I encourage them for what they are already doing rather than when
I scold them for their lack of action. Indeed, if I am seen to be attacking
leaders in any way they tend to become defensive or stay away from seminars on
youth ministry. My role as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator includes the
development of intentionality in the church’s ministry with young people, even
in the face of apathy, despair, depression, anger and passive aggressive
behaviour. . The message I aim to leave wherever I go is "You can do it".
Healing
Greenleaf lists healing as one of the
characteristics of servant leadership. This can be understood as the ability to
help with the healing of difficult situations, or the capacity to help make
whole those people and institutions with whom the servant leader comes in
contact. As National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator I have the opportunity to
stimulate the formation of healthy relationships within the church, as well as
the development of healthy leaders. Callahan states that the "effective leader’s
role includes the construction of new communities of reconciliation, wholeness,
caring and justice – in the name of Christ. This is what healthy congregations
is about - promoting a sense of interconnectedness, collegiality and trust
between people sharing the call to ministry with young people and others in the
Christian community.
Persuasion
Spears points out that "Servant-leaders" will
use an ability to persuade and develop consensus, rather than resort to using
positional authority to coerce people into compliance. I believe that this was a
choice made by Jesus, illustrated in the temptation narrative. He struggled with
the "easy options" of selfish use of power, playing to the crowd, and using the
authority vested in position to get his way. In practice, Jesus chose to work as
part of a community of vulnerable and fallible people who were often slow to
understand his purpose and direction. I find that mutual dialogue and shared
decision-making are essential tools for the development of vision and purpose in
the national team of leaders. Without these, an atmosphere of suspicion,
hostility and competition soon develops.
Awareness
Another component of servant leadership is
awareness – both general awareness and self-awareness. Spears comments that
awareness aids the leader in understanding issues involving ethics and values,
and enables one to approach situations from a more integrated, holistic
position. As editor of Crumbs Youth Ministry magazine I have a mandate to
share with those in youth ministry a broad spectrum of issues relating to work
with young people. I recently had a letter of complaint from a reader who felt
that Crumbs was little different to secular magazines. In my reply I
explained that one of the purposes of Crumbs is to integrate the social
sciences with the Biblical perspectives and goals we have as Christian youth
leaders and policy makers. A poignant example of this occurred in 1997 when I
noticed news items and statistics that indicated an alarming rate of youth
suicide in New Zealand. As co-editor of Crumbs magazine, I commissioned
four writers to develop succinct articles for youth leaders. The resulting issue
of Crumbs magazine included both an analysis of the broad issues in
relation to Christian youth ministry, along with pointers for action at local
and national levels.
Self-Awareness
A key factor in my leadership at a national
level is my awareness of my own leadership styles. This includes an ongoing
appreciation of my own strengths and weaknesses, my motivations, and the
conditions in which I react rather than act proactively. I am generally high in
people orientation although highly motivated to achieve in relation to task
orientation, which means that I often aim to achieve more than is humanly
possible. I have a high capacity to engage in a number of projects at
once. This means that I periodically experience difficulty in completing tasks
on time. In response to this I am developing a strategy of contracting other
team members to pick up time-consuming tasks that I don’t need to do personally.
I am learning to limit my involvement in some projects even when I know I could
do them well. When I fail to examine my own motivations and weaknesses I suffer
for it, along with those who have to live with my stressed lifestyle and missed
deadlines.
Foresight
Greenleaf identifies foresight as the "central
ethic of leadership". As National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator I aim to develop
understanding based on the lessons of the past, the realities of the present,
and the likely consequences of current decisions for the future. This involves
skills of historical research and analysis, as well as skills of future
projection. In the months before beginning in my present position, I had the
privilege of developing a seventy-year overview of the Presbyterian Church’s
national and regional staffing for youth ministry in New Zealand. I was able to
explore the rise and fall of the Bible Class movement, and attempts at
developing a Christian Youth movement to take its place. Insights gained in this
exercise included the wisdom of developing a broad range of ages in the
governance of youth ministry at local, regional and national levels. As National
Youth Ministry Co-ordinator I make a point of helping members of the
Presbyterian congregations think carefully about the likely future that will be
passed on to future generations.
The characteristic of foresight is closely
related to intuition and hope, both of which are core parts of my personality.
In Hopgood’s words, I have a commitment to tomorrow,
an "unwillingness to stop thinking about it." Easum talks about being "willing
to concentrate on the opportunities rather than the threats." I am inspired by
the foresight exemplified in his questions:
"What are the things congregations do today
that no longer make sense?" Why do we insist on doing them? What are the
implications of not doing them? Is it possible to redirect them toward relevant,
redemptive ministries? What can we make possible today in our ministry to make
our congregations more vital and relevant tomorrow?"
Leader as Dreamer
Another element of servant leadership
identified by Greenleaf is conceptualisation, the ability to dream great dreams
and think beyond day-to-day management realities. A member of a peer support
group, in my previous position as parish minister, encouraged me with the words,
"If anyone has permission to be crazy in the Presbyterian Church, it would have
to be the National Youth Co-ordinator." I have taken those words seriously.
Although I have responsibility for paying accounts, maintaining databases and
answering requests for resources, I set aside time for thinking outside the
square and developing new approaches to youth ministry. This happens most
effectively when I am working with a group of lateral thinkers. Developments
such as "alternative worship experiences" and the creative presentation of
resources and workshops around New Zealand are stimulated by a commitment to
bring fresh approaches to congregational ministry with young people.
Commitment to the growth of people
Servant leadership is characterised by a
commitment to the growth of people. Spears explains that the servant leader
perceives the intrinsic value of people, a value that goes beyond their tangible
contributions as workers. In terms of corporate leadership, this means a concern
for the personal, professional and spiritual growth of everyone within an
organisation. My ministry as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator goes beyond
providing skills and resources for youth-related tasks in church youth groups.
Leadership training for youth ministry at national, regional and local levels
includes space for personal formation.
Authority shared
An important part of personal development in
youth leaders is the sharing of authority alongside responsibility. As I write
this paper I am preparing to meet with a group of ministers and youth leaders in
South Auckland to discuss the possibility of them hosting a national forum on
youth ministry in 2000. I will be endeavouring to build a partnership in which
the local group shares decision-making with me and the National Youth Ministry
Workgroup. While I will have strong input into the focus of the forum, I hope to
give this group the power to make decisions about the atmosphere and direction.
Likewise, the group will need to share out responsibilities along with freedom
to act, so that there is a strong sense of participation in the South Auckland
area.
Mission Leadership
Having explored the character of the leader
in terms of servanthood and people-orientation, I will now explore the mission
goals of leadership as they relate to my role as National Youth Ministry
Co-ordinator in the Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand. In this section
I will examine the implications of outcome-based strategies relating to local
congregations and regional structures relating to the growth of healthy youth
ministry.
Equipping local congregations
My primary focus as National Youth Ministry
Co-ordinator is on equipping local congregations to recognise and achieve their
God-given ministry and mission with young people. Central to my understanding of
this is a deepening awareness of the ministry and mission of Jesus, and of the
church’s role in living that out.
One of the tools I use when working with
congregations and their leaders is the "Comprehensive Approach to Ministry with
Children, Young People and Adults." Leaders are encouraged to explore the work
of Jesus Christ, and in turn his people, in eight broad categories: advocacy,
Christian education, prayer and worship, leadership development, pastoral care,
peace and justice, evangelism and community. Using this scheme congregations
discover that youth ministry is much broader than they had previously envisaged.
With encouragement members learn to recognise and value youth ministry in its
existing settings, as well as dream about new possibilities.
Focus on foundational searches
Callahan talks about the missionary pastor, as
leader, being preoccupied with helping the grouping to discover fulfilment in
its foundational searches. These foundational searches he identifies as
individuality, community, meaning and hope. While Callahan is trying to steer
the Church away from materialistic concerns, his approach here could easily be
used to pander to consumerism. At the same time I see in the life of Jesus a
concern for the fulfilment of persons, "life in all its fullness". I work with
this pattern with the provision that the human searches identified by Callahan
are lined up alongside God’s search for those who are poor, disadvantaged,
neglected or excluded.
As a leader in the field of youth ministry I
have potential to help individuals rediscover power in their own lives and
destinies. I gain a great deal of satisfaction from the look on peoples’ faces
as they realise that they can contribute to the growth of new generations. The
most poignant example I can remember is at a women’s conference where Stan
Stewart and I were the speakers. We were addressing the theme of "Welcoming the
Stranger". We picked up the anguish felt by many mothers and grandmothers as
they observed the disturbing youth suicide statistics. Every available copy of
the Crumbs issue on youth suicide was snatched up. In response Stan
pointed out that those present, individually and corporately could save the
lives of young adults by befriending them in times of transition. People left
that conference with a sense of hope.
Reconciling Communities
The provision of this sense of hope is
extended to whole congregations and communities. I believe that I have a role to
play in helping congregations construct new communities of reconciliation, where
wholeness, caring and justice are experienced in the name of Jesus Christ.
Obviously the birth and growth of various types of youth groups is a central
part of this community development. I have a vision of the birth and development
of new congregations specifically designed to be hospitable for emerging
generations. In a broader sense, I am working on ways of encouraging
congregations to develop their wider communities as places of reconciliation
between young and old.
My role as National Youth Ministry
Co-ordinator involves a degree of leadership in sharing new theological
directions and specific, shared purposes for youth ministry. Every two years I
have the privilege of hosting Youth Assembly, a national forum on youth ministry
in the Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New Zealand. This is a key time for
sharing vision, discerning together the implications of what it means to follow
Jesus Christ in youth ministry at this time. The most recent Youth Assembly,
held in July 1998, was on the theme of Breaking the Barriers. Leaders and
young people were encouraged to go back to their own communities to build strong
relationships between young and old, between the church and its wider community.
The next forum, to be held in the year 2000, will focus on healthy youth
ministry.
The Importance of Joining
I believe that credibility as a mission leader
comes only after being seen to join the team as a member, or a player. Corporate
trust is becoming as important as personal trust. I make it clear in my work at
a national level that I am a practitioner seeking understanding, as much as a
coach providing a process for team development. I am a member of a youth
ministry team in my own local parish. I am also involved in the development of
worship and community with the aim of including children, teenagers, young
adults, and their families. I work with a team of people in my local community
to run a music centre for children and young people. Through my job as National
Youth Ministry Co-ordinator I become involved in other congregations seeking
ways of working with children, young people and families. Through research,
writing, teaching, and networking, I seek to provide stimulus for local youth
ministry in 450 parishes linked with the Presbyterian Church of Aotearoa New
Zealand.
Making a difference in the lives of young people
Callahan identifies a strategic role for
mission leadership: the "launching and leading of intentional missional teams to
meet specific, concrete human hurts and hopes – both societal and individual –
in the world". My role as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator would be merely
bureaucratic co-ordination if it were not for my weekly involvement in local
youth ministry that takes seriously the longings and concerns of teenagers and
young adults. Sitting down to share a plate of popcorn with a young person
provides me with a regular reminder that youth ministry is about real people
rather than church growth, the survival of the denomination, or another
professional project.
As National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator I
cannot take part in the leadership of mission in every congregation, as I would
in my own local church. Nevertheless, I have a role in helping congregations
notice and address the hurts and hopes of young people in their own local
community. Once again, using the Comprehensive Approach with congregations has
equipped people to think beyond the age-based models such as youth groups to a
plethora of relationships with young people in the contexts of family, church
community, schools and workplaces. As congregations work through this approach
they are less likely to use the inward-looking phrase "We have no young people".
Manager or leader
My ministry as National Youth Ministry
Co-ordinator has its basis in the mission orientation of the church, rather than
in a management-oriented preservation of the institution. Stevens and Collins
clearly state, "The goal of leadership should conform to the goal of the church:
mission in the world not ecclesiastical self-enrichment." I face a continual
tension between the development of national and regional structures, and the
growth of mission and ministry with young people in local contexts. In theory
national structures should help the local congregation to do the work of
Christ’s mission. In practice, local leaders and young people can become merely
contributors to the projects of the National Youth Ministry Workgroup. Although
I have a responsibility for overseeing the wise use of resources, I am committed
to keeping my focus on positive leadership.
Relational Mission Leadership
Leadership is relational rather than
organisational. This was driven home to me when only five people turned up to a
seminar on a comprehensive approach to mission and ministry with young people,
children and adults in Hawkes Bay. The next day twenty-five people turned up at
a seminar I ran for their congregation on developing fresh approaches to
worship. For the first seminar I had relied on email messages and notices sent
out by the sponsoring organisations. I learnt later that Presbyterians would
have been put off by the venue, a Pentecostal church, and by the fact that the
event was being run by strongly evangelical organisations. The Pentecostals were
not inspired by the wording that had been used to describe my workshop. Three
out of the five people who did attend the seminar knew me personally and
attended for that reason. The second seminar followed a worship service in which
I played a part, using energetic music, humour and movement. Even more important
though, was the fact that this congregation had identified that the development
of worship was a high priority and had asked me to work with them in this area.
Competence and Trust
One model I have found helpful is the
development of competencies at local and regional levels. Roland Martinson talks
about youth ministry focusing on "individuals with a living faith who love kids
and possess the knowledge and skill to nurture faith and life in children, youth
and their families." He goes on to describe the skills of developing
a team of leaders who can work with young people. At a broader level, Martinson
describes those with a competency in the area of congregational development,
changing the culture of the local church so that young people will be welcomed
and involved in the ministry and mission of the church. A further competency
involves transformation of the wider community. Finally Martinson introduces the
skills of research, networking and training that equip people in the first four
levels of competency. He stresses that credibility and expertise at any level is
based on the competency at an earlier level.
Proactive Leadership
Mission leadership is being spoken about in
business circles as being basically proactive rather than reactive, intentional
rather than responsive. I am finding that taking this approach to co-ordination
of youth ministry at a national level has freed me from the bind of
administrative roles linked with involvement in Assembly structures. Likewise
this approach has liberated me from merely responding to the requests of leaders
wanting a programme to get them through the next meeting with their young
people. My work is most effective when it is the result of focus and intention,
as in workshops teaching local leaders the principles of choosing and adapting
prepared material as well as creating their own home-grown programmes.
Proactivity is a key element in the most
visible part of my work at a national level, the production of Crumbs, a
youth ministry magazine and web site. Together with colleagues from the
Anglican, Methodist and Catholic churches, I am continually developing and
working with a two-year plan for Crumbs. This plan is built around topics
that will grow healthy youth ministry. We want congregational leaders as well as
youth leaders to be aware of the issues facing young people and those who work
with them. Some of our issues of Crumbs are deliberately linked with
forthcoming training or with correspondence courses and further reading
material.
In 1997 a key issue of Crumbs focused
on "Family and Youth Ministry", with the intention of broadening the mainline
churches’ view of youth ministry to include the impact of family on leaders and
on young people. A later issue focused on the prevention of various forms of
abuse in youth ministry, exploring issues of power, and helping people to think
ahead before they accepted volunteers or employees in their work with young
people. At the same time as the magazine was being produced, a correspondence
course on professional ethics was being developed and local churches were
encouraged to develop their own codes of practice for youth ministry. The
December 1997 issue of Crumbs, dedicated to the interaction between
technology and relational youth ministry, was released as both a printed
magazine and the initial contents of the Crumbs web site.
Continuity
The development of Crumbs as a
respected youth ministry magazine has taken over twelve years, of which only
five have been linked with my ministry. I am reminded that the development of
leadership in any field takes time, perseverance and continuity. Callahan points
out that "it takes three to four years of living with a people to develop the
shepherding relationships of mutual trust, respect, integrity, credibility, and
confidence to emerge as a trusted leader." I was reminded of this when I asked
if it might be wise to let somebody else take up my position with new projects.
I explained that when I first began as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator I
took on five major projects, each of which had been completed in the year before
writing this paper. My colleague remarked that I had worked hard to build
networks and resources seen as credible in the eyes of Presbyterian leaders. In
his opinion, now was the time for me to reap the results from the work, while
developing fresh approaches.
Leaders grow leaders
One of the scariest moments in my job was when
one of my key advisors took me aside and indicated that I should be working
myself out of a job. I needed to be developing other people alongside me, so
that in the event of my accepting a call to another position my work would not
be lost. At first I took this as a threat. It took a week to come to terms with
the fact that I wasn’t being given notice of termination of my contract. I came
to realise that my effectiveness as a leader in the field of youth ministry
would grow only as I helped others to master the skills I had developed.
Hopgood’s advice helps me focus on the development of servant mission leadership
in others: "The best of us must help the rest of us until the rest of us are the
best of us"
Transformational Leadership
The prospect of my present role coming to an
end has brought about a clarification of my purpose and direction in the
leadership of youth ministry in New Zealand and beyond. I am not content to
co-ordinate the demise of youth ministry in the Presbyterian Church. I do not
wish to be part of a bureaucracy that seeks its own survival. I want to be part
of the transforming work of the Holy Spirit in God’s people, particularly in
relation to mission and ministry with young people. I hope that in my remaining
time I will be able to motivate old and young alike to make such a difference in
their communities that God will touch the lives and cultures of young people in
some way. I rely on God to give me the ability to "influence others so that
believers will trust and respond to the Head of the church for themselves, in
order to accomplish the Lord’s purposes for God’s people in the world".
Being transformed by God
The transformation of the church, and the
equipping of those in youth ministry, requires leaders who themselves are being
transformed by God. At the heart of my ministry as National Youth Ministry
Co-ordinator is a relationship with God, in Jesus Christ, through the Holy
Spirit, that changes me. I am talking about more than communication skills
needed for relating to young people and adults. I have been focusing on the
quality of leadership that God calls me to, which is present in who I am as much
as in what I do and how I do it.
Conclusion: Servant Mission Leadership for Youth Ministry
When I first began research for this paper, I
was curious to see the relationship between my national co-ordination of youth
ministry and my denomination’s call for servant mission leadership at local and
regional levels. I struggled through many of the insights covered in this paper
when I first began parish ministry, fresh out of seminary training. The emphases
on the development of humble partnership, integrity and vulnerability, as
modelled by Jesus were not easy to live out in an ecclesiastical culture that
often looked for professional caretakers. Now, in a national position, I
struggle to find a community in which I can live out a life of open servanthood.
My local church provides me with a test of reality – in which my national
leadership is proved in the quality of my relationship with young people and
other leaders.
In my current position, I believe I have a
call and responsibility to lead congregations to be effective in ministry and
mission with young people. Responding to that call requires careful nurture of
relationships with people throughout the church and wider community. Without
succumbing to servitude, I am intentionally looking for ways of serving young
people and those in youth ministry in my local community and throughout the
Christian community in New Zealand. Being a servant does not rule out making an
impact. I believe that the quality of leadership required for the extension of
mission among young people will be that which affirms and heals people. It will
be leadership that persuades rather than controls. The influence I bring, I
hope, will be founded in care, foresight, and a commitment to the growth of
other people. My ministry as National Youth Ministry Co-ordinator depends on my
proactive and consistent equipping the church at a systemic as well as personal
level. Working with others in my team, I am focusing on releasing gifts and
abilities in others, helping the church to work together healthily, and staying
focused on the ministry of Jesus as our model.
Bibliography
Anderson, J.D. & Jones E.E. The Management of Ministry
San Francisco, Harper and Row, 1978
Callahan, Kennon Effective
Church Leadership
New York, Harper & Row, 1990
Dale, Robert D. To Dream
Again
Nashville, Tennessee, Broadman Press, 1981
Easum, William Dancing
with Dinosaurs
Nashville, Abingdon Press, 1993
Ford, Leighton
Transforming Leadership
Downers Grove, Illinois, IVP, 1991
Friedman, Edwin Generation to Generation
New York, Guilford Press, 1985
Greenleaf, Robert Servant
Leadership
Mahwah, NJ, Paulist Press, 1991
Guthrie, S, et. al. At-Risk Youth, At-Risk Church: What Jesus Christ
and American Teenagers are saying to the Mainline Church,
Princeton, Princeton Theological Seminary, 1997
Hahn, Celia Growing in Authority,
Relinquishing Control
Washington D.C., Alban Institute, 1994
Jinkins, Michael & Deborah Bradshaw Power and Change in Parish Ministry
Washington D.C., Alban Institute, 1991
Kennedy, M. & Doyle, B. Best Practice in Youth Ministry
Dublin, Columba Press, 1998
Kilinski, K. K. & Wofford, J.C. Organization and Leadership in the
Local Church
Grand Rapids, Michigan, 1973
Lee, Harris W. Effective Church LeadershipM
inneapolis, Augsburg, 1989
Marshall, Tom Understanding Leadership
Chichester, Sovereign World, 1991
Miller, Calvin The Empowered Leader
Nashville, TN, Broadman & Holman, 1995
Sanders, J. Oswald Spiritual Leadership
Chicago, Moody Bible Institute, 1980
Richardson, Ronald Creating a Healthier Church:
Family Systems Theory, Leadership and Congregational Life,
Augsburg Press, Minneapolis, 1996
Shawcuck, Norman, & Heuser, Roger Leading the Congregation
Nashville, Abingdon Press, 1993
Sofield, Loughlan and Kuhn, Donald H.
The Collaborative Leader
Notre Dame, Indiana, Ave Maria Press, 1995
Stevens, R. Paul & Collins, Phil The Equipping Pastor: A Systems
Approach to Congregational Leadership
Alban Institute, Washington, 1993
Walker, Christopher Seeking Relevant Churches for the 21st Century
JBCE, Melbourne, 1997
Warren, Rick The Purpose Driven Church
Zondervan, Grand Rapids, Michigan, 1998
Other Sources
Discussion with:
National Youth Ministry Workgroup, PCANZ, March 4 - 6, 1999,
focusing on servant mission leadership and its application in the context of
National Youth Ministry.
Kerry Enright, Assembly Executive Secretary, PCANZ, in
preparation for seminars on servant mission leadership, March 9 - 20, 1999
Keith Nisbet, Auckland Presbytery Co-ordinator of Youth
Ministries, April 22 - 23, 1999.
New Zealand Presbyterian Email Discussion List, February 11 –
13, 1999.
Greenleaf Center Web Site
http:www.greenleaf.com